Question for Girl Moms!

[NCBeachyGrl]

Hobbermitten's post got me thinking about positions! Is there any truth to the boy positions with deep penetration or the girl positions with shallow penetration? How important is position to a sway?

Both my boys were conceived by doing doggie, but starting to think maybe position doesn't really have much to do with gender if we are doing all these other things? I would love to hear from girl moms to see what positions they did!

[Mrs_P]

Unfortuantely in the same position as you but mine were conceived one with doggie, one with missionary and the other i can't remeber we were young adventerous and not trying so could have been anything

i think girl on top (sitting up) is supposed to be good for getting a girl and is def what we will try (if i'm not pg this month and get chance to sway)

[NCBeachyGrl]

I did girl on top last month and got a BFN. I just feel for me that RePhresh + FR + Zyrtec + no CM + girl on top is too much! For my next attempt I was going to back off of zyrtec and RepHresh and stop on CD10 and do missionary, but now I am wondering if I should keep all supps and jellies a go and go for doggie b/c I know it works.....hmmmmmm

[NCBeachyGrl]

Unfortuantely in the same position as you
I am so childish b/c this made me giggle!

[dloui128]

I conceived both my girls in missionary and the boy I am carrying now with doggie position

[NCBeachyGrl]

I conceived both my girls in missionary and the boy I am carrying now with doggie position

Thanks for sharing! Def. makes me scared about doggie...although I know it isn't the magic bullet to getting a boy.

[BeadinMom]

Great question, NC! Thanks for asking it! :)

[Mrs_P]

I am so childish b/c this made me giggle!

Me too know you know i never noticed - giggled that much at that now though my son asked me what was so funny :rofl:

[atomic sagebrush]

Oh jeez I thought I answered this but I must have closed the site before posting.

I do not think it's very important at all. Just like with frequency, if you studied 1000 couples who were clones and all doing everything else identically, it ~might~ make some miniscule difference but in the real world, I don't think it amounts to a hill of beans. I just mentioned this on another thread so apologies for repeating myself, but one of the women who told me about Shettles eons ago was trying for a boy and DTD doggie style...which she told me and my elderly neighbor about in positively gruesome detail (as in, I know what her husband said at the critical moment LOL and it's burned into my brain forever!!!) Baby was a girl.

[atomic sagebrush]

Oh and here's the thread on positions, this one doesn't get linked much so you may not have seen it.http://genderdreaming.com/forum/gender-swaying-discussion/1143-best-sex-positions-babies-particular-gender-just-getting-pregnant.html

[NCBeachyGrl]

REALLY!? So I shouldn't really care about doing it doggie? I would really rather keep all my swaying stuff going and try doggie than drop stuff and try missionary. Or maybe I will try a combo of both :bigsmile: Maybe I have a chance of getting pg this cycle after all!

I was so misinformed when swaying with DS2....I pretty much never understood the diet and dropped everything to get pg!

[nestof3]

Doggie here and I got 1 boy and 1 girl that way. Other boy was missionary.

[NCBeachyGrl]

Thanks everyone! This is really interesting to see positions of both genders!

[Mochagirl]

All 4 of my kids (3 boys and one girl) were conceived with missionary position.

[Pearl327]

DD was conceived on a lazy Sunday morning in missionary after running out of condoms and taking a chance

[atomic sagebrush]

Also, don't forget that virtually every blue swayer that got an opposite, was DTD doggy style because they think it's a magic bullet.

[nini]

I conceived a boy doggie and a boy and a girl missionary! Since missionary appears to be 50% for me, I should try doggie again for girl I guess, ha ha (sorry, not sure how I conceived my first, he was not planned and from a previous relationship).

[elle82]

I conceived 4 boys and 1 girl in the missionary position.

[auroara78]

DS1, I don't remember his conception, I could have been asleep, but my husband was pretty fond of doggie in those days

DS2 I tackled my husband and I think we changed positions but started off in doggy, then some other modified doggie (not missionary)

DD1 missionary (not shallow either) and so worried DH wouldn't finish because he doesn't do well in missionary. I was prepared to move into doggy if it meant he'd be able to finish, lol.

Though this makes my concpetions seem skewered (doggie for boys, missionary for girl) I really think maternal condition outweighs it all...though this is still an interesting thread!

[NCBeachyGrl]

DS1, I don't remember his conception, I could have been asleep, but my husband was pretty fond of doggie in those days

You crack me up!!!!! And the fact you could have done doggie in your sleep gives me the funniest mental image! :rofl:

I definitely think positions and swaying goes hand in hand b/c it is ingrained in your brain that doggie = boy and missionary = girl and everyone is doing all the swaying + position so it seems like position could be the magic bullet, when in reality it isn't.

[hopingforsaskia]

First DS1 was me on top, DS2 was missionary.... I hate doggie, only ever do it for a quickie (DH gets there really fast! yay! haha) Nothing to it in my opinion.. at least, not as much as many other sway factors. :)

[dramabird]

I did girl on top last month and got a BFN. I just feel for me that RePhresh + FR + Zyrtec + no CM + girl on top is too much! For my next attempt I was going to back off of zyrtec and RepHresh and stop on CD10 and do missionary, but now I am wondering if I should keep all supps and jellies a go and go for doggie b/c I know it works.....hmmmmmm

For what it's worth, NC, the month that I conceived this baby (don't know gender yet), it was with RepHresh + FR + no CM + me on top (so, everything you have listed above except for Zyrtec ... we also used saliva for lube, which isn't conception friendly, either). However, we did BD through O, so we got several viable attempts in ... that evidently helped balance the other sway extremes.

GL!!

[mis2ninos]

Conceived both dd and ds missionary. Will try missionary again but more shallow release if dh can control it