Dr. Jonas Theory - was it right for you?

[Pumpkin2011]

I found this article and would like to know if it was right for you. It was right with DS and is now predicting a girl for me.

You would need to know when you O'd for sure because even one day could make a difference.

Here is a link to the article:

DR JONAS METHOD - Gender Selection, Contraception, Natural Fertility, Miscarriage, Birth Defects (http://www.drjonasmethod.com/index.php?fuseaction=services.officialresults)

And here is a gender calendar which is going by this method. You just need to fill in the day you O'd and it'll tell you your babies gender.

Baby gender calendar (http://www.magic-horoscope.com/baby-gender/index.php)

[strawberrymom]

For this baby it is correct.

[a&jmummy]

Correct for my two! Wow

[Pangea]

It's right for both of my boys and predicts another boy for me. It's odd I started putting in ovulation dates from loads of months I didn't conceive when TTC in the past (cycles are all stored in fertility friend) and it comes up boy every time. I just never ovulate on their girl days. I hope there's nothing to it! Not just because it predicts this baby is a boy, but because I only ever ovulate on boy days!

[atomic sagebrush]

Wrong for boys, right for DD

PLEASE don't put stock into these things ladies. Just for fun.

[lime]

50% chance of it being correct ; )

[Rosie85]

Correct for all three of mine!

[Kiara]

It was right for both my dd and the one in my belly. But it has 50% chance so..;)

[HopefulMonster]

Correct for mine, BUT... it is using the moon sign when you conceive and as the egg lives approx. 20hrs or so, and you can only roughly know when you ovulate, it's a bit iffy imo.

Say I get a +opk on the 9th then a temp rise on the 11th so I can confidently say I ovulated on the 10th...what time on the 10th did I ovulate? If it is right before midnight, then the egg lasts 20 more hours before fertilisation, I could actually get pregnant on the day after, in a different moon sign!

It's impossible to know that accurately without HT scans etc, so it's actually very clever and has a more then 50% "accuracy" because you could argue that you conceived earlier or later than you actually did... does that make sense?

[Alyssasmom789]

I wish it was right!!! I'd be prego with a boy now :/

[Pangea]

I'm not liking this at all, it seems to have a very high accuracy rate. How could it work though, it's just astrology. I wonder what time zone they are using.

[myrainbowgirl]

A little reassurance that this doesn't work...It was right for DS1, but wrong for DS2 & DS 3. :)

[onebigwish]

Both Boys predicted correct

[Satox3]

Wrong for me, one ds predicted dd.

[auroara78]

this calendar worked for DS1 and DD but got DS2 wrong--which astrology calendars often get him wrong.

[diamond13]

Wrong for my last one.