Originally Posted by
atomic sagebrush
95% of everyone who gets their period is ovulating. You could be in that 5%, I suppose. Do I think that's what is happening - no. I think you're ovulating and not getting a temp rise for some reason (bad thermometer or because you're nursing, sometimes nursing disrupts your sleep to such an extent that you cannot temp, it won't work because you haven't had long enough not disrupted sleep.)
People on websites and scientists like to lay out these beautiful theoretical scenarios with stages and symptoms and bladiblah but that is NOT how it goes for most people, that's why people can and do catch the first egg while breastfeeding. Yes, totally normal to have fertility come back gradually but I really think you're taking it far too literally, most people do NOT go through those stages and simply wake up one day with their period and everything goes back to normal again. Others may have a couple months with a short LP and then back to normal. Everyone is different and the fact is that the older your baby gets the more likely it is that things will return to normal, and so even if your O is missing due to nursing, the prescription is the same - wait till your body produces a viable egg and be in a position to catch it.
What they mean when they say "the more gradual return of full fertility" simply means that a woman who gets her cycle back at 6 weeks PP is probably not going to be back to full fertility for another few months compared to someone who got their cycle back at 18 months PP. Does NOT mean that anyone who got their cycle back early is doomed to have a slow return to fertility that takes years, not at all, and in fact I sometimes see people who get their cycle back early who are actually highly fertile, that's why their bodies think "hmm I could handle another baby, I'll start ovulating again".
We have noticed that while breastfeeding we sometimes will have "practice cycles" where our bodies gear up to ovulate but nursing suppresses it and then you don't get AF (most of the time.) Now, this may be what is happening to you, again, do I think this is that likely, I honestly don't. Breakthrough bleeding, while it can rarely happen monthly and can rarely be just like a normal period, is usually very irregular and unexpected, it doesn't happen right when you expect AF to come and 7-14 days after you had ovulation symptoms. It comes out of seemingly nowhere, is unusually heavy and seems like old dark blood or unusually light and just carries on spotting for a while, and not ~usually~ regular predictable cycles.
So, what you're describing to me is possible. Not likely but possible. But even if it is the case that this is going on, the cure (while rather dull) is simply waiting it out and you will eventually O and catch the egg.