Printable View
so i caught a post about someone having a PGD opposite. obviously its human error...read the test wrong or whatever (i dont know much about PGD).
anyone know how many cases like this? is this risk getting higher? so is PGD no longer considered GUARANTEED????
i understand dr potter's clinic has not had an inciddent so for, yes???
this kinda freaked me out..esply if i have to do all thsi convincing plus saving of money, plus emotional prep, etc....
kinda scary!
PGD is never 100 percent guarenteed but almost 100 percent.
so then what makes ppl pay all that money and go thru all that procedure?
i know, i heard its like 99 point something percent. but just wondering if there are any updated statistics on successful live baby desired-genders being born? and the opposites? and what clinics have made mistakes (US? abroad?)
It's really not something to spend time worrying about.
With FISH, it's due to human error. That happened on here and the other was from using day 3 CGH which should not be used for GS.
If you use Natera, because of the parental check part where DNA is verified, it won't happen. It won't with FISH either unless there is negligence of some sort.
There are risks to worry about, mostly it not working at all. About a 50% chance of that!!
It's the ONLY way to get a guarantee. That's why we pay "all that money". And no, there's no stats for worst case scenario. It's happened once for FISH and twice for day 3 CGH. The day 3 CGH can be avoided.
Lots of things to worry about but that's not one of them.
I totally agree with nbp!
I agree witn nbp, after everything you put yourself through, a gender opposite is the last thing on your mind, these cases are VERY rare. Getting pregnant is the most important factor, Savvas told me of 2 cases he knows off at his clinic of gender opposites, this is a very small minority, i really wouldnt worry hun x
okay that helps a lot. yes i am mostly worried about even getting PG at all!! but if i know that there is even a slight chance that id get an opposite...i feel like i might as well just try naturally!!
when you say "50% chance of not working at all"...do you mean 50% chance of not getting PG?
thanks everyone!
Yes. Your biggest risk is "paying all this money" and coming out of it with no baby.
The opposite issue is there because human beings are a part of the process and when humans are involved, errors can happen. That's life I guess.
It's not something to sit and worry about. If you go through this process, you will quickly realize that most of it is stressful and there are so many other what-ifs along the way, this will quickly take a back seat.
Totally, getting an opposite is the LAST thing I am worried about right now - it really is such a rare thing. Just getting one or two of my desired gender is what I am worried about right now and then having the embryo acutally implant is my next worry. It's funny how I thought the money was going to be a worry at first or getting an opposite, now it's all changed! Good luck to you gizmo!
I have read aboout this happening twice on ingender, once for a singleton pregnancy and once for a twin pregnancy where she got one of the desired gender. I would not worry about it, its very very rare!
And what about a testing aCGH on day 5 ? Is this as accurate as natera for gender ?Quote:
Originally Posted by nuthinbutpink
Depends I suppose on who you ask. Even Dr Potter said that aCGH is a very reliable technique for PGD when he was still doing day 3 Natera. I think at HRC they have had one opposite with CGH (not someone on the site) and Dr P said that 1 in the 1000's they have done is still extremely accurate.Quote:
Originally Posted by ROSCAR
The key is to go to a good clinic with a good reputation, I know mine has 2 doctors read and report on the findings, so a slip up is even harder.
I used CGH and I think I would of been just as worried about getting the wrong gender if I had used Natera or FISH.
I am supposed to start a new cycle with Dr Potter and really wonder about the best option between aCGH D5 or Natera D5Quote:
Originally Posted by glory
So you think that aCGH D5 with Dr Potter is fine ?
And my other concern is about best transfer option : fresh or FET ?
For me, day 5 testing with FET was best, but so many people get pregnant on a fresh cycle.
But everyone is different. The pros of doing Natera and a FET for travellers are you only have to be there for ER, then you can go home and do FET if you have something available for transfer.
If you stay for the CGH you may not get a transfer and have stayed another 6 days longer.
If you do a FET, you know you have something for transfer, but there is the rare chance it does not thaw, it does take time to do a cycle, then a FET.
I don't think there is a right or wrong answer, just what you can fit into your life. If going to the US twice is not an issue, then do the FET, if you have to make it one big holiday, do the fresh. For me this would be more of an issue than a gender opposite.
We all worry about it and it is a possibility for any testing (in my opinion) but it really should be the least of our worries.
Thanks Glory. I know about the NT : this is the way my first cycle finished in january !!
Thiis is hard decision
Of course we can stay there 2 weeks, and we prefer travelling from europe for 2 weeks only once (less tiring & we save money : one ticket plane & the cost of FET)
And don't tell my husband this is a great holiday : He says it's not holidays at all for him (such a rollercoaster !!!) Lol !!
I think going high tech is very stressful as there are so many decisions to be made ( how many to put back) hoping you get a transfer of the gender you want. I haven't started yet and all I do is think and worry will it work for me.
Good luck Gizmo, you've come to the right place to ask questions and get the support you need. We have learned so much and you will too!!
Worrying about an opposite from PGD is like not wanting to eat at Mc Donald's because a meteor might burst through the roof and hit you while you're eating. Mc Donald's might kill ya, but the odds are very high it's gonna be heart disease and not a meteor. PGD may not work out for ya, but the odds are all but 100% that if it doesn't work, it will be because you don't get pg, not because of a PGD opposite!
Good luck Giz, rooting for you. :)
We have not had a gender opposite in my laboratory using IVF/PGD. We are taking steps to further strengthen aCGH with GenderSure which involves a day 4 biopsy with aCGH plus PCR on the X and Y. GenderSure will come with a 100%, money back guarantee for correct gender.Quote:
Originally Posted by gizmo77
Lol Atomic :-))