Another proof about weight and conceiving girls

[rainbowflower]

I don't think that weight itself actually sways - the Oxford study showed that boy mums2be and girl mums2be had IDENTICAL BMIs. If weight swayed, you'd expect to see a difference.

Perhaps those you know who were overweight were trying to lose weight and it was the weight loss that swayed pink?

[atomic sagebrush]

I don't think that weight itself actually sways - the Oxford study showed that boy mums2be and girl mums2be had IDENTICAL BMIs. If weight swayed, you'd expect to see a difference.

Perhaps those you know who were overweight were trying to lose weight and it was the weight loss that swayed pink?

I have another study that does indicate weight itself matters - I think it's the one in the link below.

[atomic sagebrush]

Well, I was very, very overweight with ds1 and 2, in the obese category. Between ds 2 and 3, I got a lap band and lost 80 pounds and still another boy. I blame my husband lol

None of this is 100% unfortunately!

[atomic sagebrush]

I just can't win...I have been scary skinny for my first...healthy weight range and looking good for #2....a little chubby for #3....overweight for #4.....obese for #5....still all girls!! I lost a heap of weight about 2yrs ago and have steadily been gaining on the boy diet....possibly overweight now but not obese like with DD#5.

It's not weight per se that sways tho, it's what goes on in your body as a result of that weight. If your fertility is slightly reduced at any weight, you're more likely to conceive a girl. It's jsut that being very thin does tend to reduce fertility in a pretty reliable way for most people, plus, it's good for most of us to lose a little weight anyway.

http://genderdreaming.com/forum/gend...irls-boys.html

[HopeandDreamG]

I didn't read through this whole thread so maybe what I am about to say has already been stated. I was very heavy when I conceived both my sons. Ds1 was conceived 1st attempt, ds2 an oopsie. Both times I was gaining weight. I think its the process of what's happening like gaining or losing not your weight, not where your weight is/except when your weight is effecting your fertility negatively which sways girl. I conceived a girl as I was losing weight consistently each week. Again an oopsie.

[hbcd123]

mmmm very interseting!! when i concieved my ds i was 22 and i was 156lbs and when i concieved my dd i was 32 and i was 135lbs now swaying girl im 128 lbs but been here for a year and cant seem to loose!!

[The Anchor]

I have two girlfriends, both overweight, both with 2 daughters. And the thing is, these women are on PERPETUAL diets, I mean always. I'm fairly convinced that they have hormonal issues, because they really don't eat much, at least when we're out to lunch or something, and they are always discussing the latest "diet".

I think it's been said...seems like the over/underweight ladies are pink moms and the "average" are blue moms...at least in my circle!

[atomic sagebrush]

Anyone who's interested in more about this topic, please read the following:

http://genderdreaming.com/forum/gend...irls-boys.html

http://genderdreaming.com/forum/gend...ypothesis.html

[AMY]

Hi pinksapphire, I feel your pain, sister! I know and see heaps of overweight women with all daughters too. AND i have a very very thin girlfriend who has all daughters, so it makes sense. ANd I am stuck in the middle! There is nothing for us to do but stress that we aren't fat enough and not skinny enough! Now that i am swaying myself i do find myself analysing every single lady and then poking my head into the pram to see what gender they have in there! It's like I am running some kind of survey in my brain! I am officially a weirdo!

So funny, I am doing the exact same thing. And I noticed I can tell the gender by the mothers appearance with 80% accurancy.