I feel like this might depend on the area of North America you live in, the preference for boys vs girls. I live in the Northern US, primarily farming outside of the few major cities and boys are very much preferred. I don't think you can generalize the entire continent? And food for thought, if you had only girls, maybe you would have a different perspective...i.e. North Americans prefer boys? I had GD after having one girl in the US, and I don't feel like I'm the only one who was hit with negative comments regarding girls...it definitely might depend on the region, but please don't assume the preference for girls exists everywhere in NA. I am now pregnant with a boy, and have yet to encounter one negative comment regarding having a boy, and I feel as though I am very aware of any gender related comments.
Results 21 to 30 of 56
Thread: Some thoughts on OCD
-
March 16th, 2015, 12:24 PM #21
-
March 16th, 2015, 12:40 PM #22
I think there's a strong preference for "pigeon pairs" in a lot of N. Am and it makes it feel like those of us who have only one or the other feels like a conspiracy or something. I also live in a farming area in the North and I felt like everyone was in my face about having a girl, but I def. know of others who had all girls who were also getting comments about it at the same time.
I do think there's a strong pref. for just girls or only girls amongst a certain and possibly more vociferous group of people, though.
I keep coming back in my mind to how much of this has to do with marketing...while I do think that gender desire is innate, there is just such a push to buy the "girl stuff" and the "boy stuff" and how it's like you're missing out if you don't get to do both, yk?!!! Questions??Check out the NEW and improved Complete Index !!!
If you appreciate my help with your sway plan, please consider a donation:
https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=C92U9TVWTRTDQ
-
March 16th, 2015, 02:26 PM #23
Well fair enough.
I apologize for generalizing.
For sure in the regions I grew up in there is a strong preference for girls. It's rather hard to not notice, especially when shopping and finding nothing but girl clothes and accessories and a token single shelf of boy things.
I also got an awful lot of snide anti-boy comments even with my very first son.
Atomic - I agree that pigeon pairs are the 'golden' family makeup. However it sure seems that two girls are better accepted than two boys, at least where I live.Me (38) and DH (38)
SAHM military momma toDS1 (2004),
DS2 (who's all boy but loves to dance, though not in a tutu!) (2006),
DS3 (2009), and our rainbow baby girl DD1 (2017)
early m/c Jan 2013
Cycle #1 @ HRC (Oct 2014) - 6 retrieved, 4 mature, 3 fertilized and biopsied. 1XX and 1XY abnormal. 1XX no DNA found, rebiopsied and found normal, frozen.
FET attempt #1 (Nov 2014) - cancelled due to functional cyst. FET attempt #2 (Jan 30, 2015) - NT. Remaining embie failed to thaw.
May 2015 - started infertility treatments at OFC. Femara 2.5mg
July 2015 - BFP after second round of Femara. Aug 4 2015 -6w4d
Dec 21 2015 -mmc 7w1d
Apr 2016 - IVF Cycle #2. Converted to IUI because of uneven response and leading follicles.
Apr 19, 2016 - IUI with 3 mature follicles (2 right, 1 left), post wash: 17mil, 94% motility and 89% rapid motility. BFN.
June 3, 2016 -5mg Femara cycle. 5w.
Sep 1, 2016 -5mg Femara cycle. 8w.
Our rainbow baby girl arrived on Mon Aug 28, 2017 - "After every storm comes a rainbow". We are so thankful and grateful for every moment.
-
March 16th, 2015, 02:42 PM #24
I do agree with the PP, I had a strong desire for a DS first and then a DD, and have no clue what my experience would have been had I had 2 DS or 2DD, but I do know all gender comments regarding each of my children has dramatically decreased. People just don't have much to say, nor can they really, so after suffering from very bad GD, it's nice to have some relief. Although I do crave for another family member to have a DD as their first, all of my extended family has either all boys or a few boys then a girl, and I feel quite alone and wish to share the experience of someone else in my close circle having a girl first
-
March 16th, 2015, 02:47 PM #25
Sorry you got snide anti boy comments with your first! Regardless of gender, I think its so hard to get slammed with gender comments, especially with your first. I mean doesn't a woman have enough going nk during her first pregnancy to no have fend off gender comments? Although never acceptable, at least in later pregnancies you know how much you will love your child and how much they add to your life!
-
March 16th, 2015, 02:57 PM #26
I would not be surprised if boys are more preferred/less snubbed in more rural communities. I think the girl preference is generally urban. Quite possibly there are class issues too but not sure I should go there!
My Ovulation Chart currently TTC, Cycle #16 since last BFP
TTC #1- swaying pink on & off since Nov 2013 - hoping for a girl first but excited for either!
Dec 2001 - May 2006 : 5 early abortions of healthy singletons (3 medical @5w, 2 surgical @8w, last 4 pregnancies conceived with late DH, all conceived while TTA/on birth control)
Mar 2012: miscarried B/G twins @5w (conceived 2 cycles after remověng Paraguard copper IUD while NTNP), one twin was ovarian ectopic
Me: 34, widowed, late O + short LP, normal-good hormone levels excepting undetectable testosterone, seeking a known sperm donor/life partner
My sway: vegetarian LE for over 28w, skipping breakfast, fibre (ground psyllium husks) with/before/between meals, physically inactive, drama avoidance, ocassional minimal YesBaby lube as needed, alternate cycles on low dose Clomid, double shot lattes (with meals)
Past sway tactics I've dropped (in order): Vitex, Sudafed, antihistamines, intermittent fasting, one attempt per cycle at positive OPK, one attempt in fertile period
-
March 16th, 2015, 03:12 PM #27Big Dreamer
- Join Date
- Oct 2012
- Posts
- 284
I think advertising is absolutely one of the biggest sources of this. I think pigeon pairs are over-represented in advertising because it is a sort of generic model for a family and it shows a product is good for everyone. I understand why advertisers do it but when nearly every image of a family you see has two opposite sex parents, a boy, and a girl it has an effect on how people view families that don't fit this model.
-
March 16th, 2015, 04:40 PM #28Dream Vet
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
- Location
- cali
- Posts
- 2,347
I come from a family of ocd. I'm not diagnosed but I acknowledge some of my tendencies. Then I hear my kids saying "weird" things and asking me why I do certain things. So far it hasn't interfered with my life but occasionally there will be tiny things like leaving the house late bc I want to empty my bladder. I can't use public restrooms. I do bc I'm forcing and talking myself into it and mostly to show my kids it's normal.
But I have 3 girls? When I 1st came on this site ready to sway, I was like " but I DO eat like that (or want to eat like that) or I AM like that...rigid, etc."
I think that's why it didn't work for me bc I didn't really change myself dramatically. It was more k allowed myself to be what I always wanted. But I always held back bc of gaining weight and not being liked.
I also wonder why there are so many posters on here who desire girls. I was in fact shocked at 1st. Doesn't everyone want a boy???
But I have resolved to eventually give up (tho i don't know if I truly can deep down) only bc I know I can't keep going HT forever. We don't have that money and I would feel just awful "damaging" our family based on my selfish desires. And I see my girls' faces and I woukdnt bear to look into them had I putpisrlh put us in debt at their cost of enjoyment. But the I think, I'll just go back to work and that will be HT money. So I don't knowif it will ever end?
Polpectomy/Hysteroscopy complete (2 polyps)
June ER @ HRC
30 retrieved, 24 mature, 23 fertilized, 17 to biopsy, 5 normal, 2xy!, 1 transferred, 1 frozen
HB seen at 6w4d!
I can't believe I did this!
My HT son
My family is complete. Baby fever resolved!
-
March 16th, 2015, 06:05 PM #29
My boys are all going to go to a Montesorri school so hoping that will do wonders for them. I salut parents who home school. I can't wait to get 'my break' lol.
I think ADD people can have some OCD tendancies like I do, even some aspegers. Maybe it has something to do with my GD but I have never thought about it before. Maybe I am procrastinating on other important things in life I should be doing by thinking I first need a girl to be complete. Who knows, could be. Us ADDers sure love to dream though and I dreamed from a young age what my family make-up would be like and it included both genders (with more boys). That's what I grew up in being the eldest of a GGB family and the media does not help. That is what I experienced and saw family as and so it has to be for me to feel complete I think.
THere is the Mum, the Dad then the boys AND girls. I always felt sorry for families of three or more of all one gender. IMO back then people with two hadn't tried enough so didn't think bad of them. And now that is me lol and I don't feel sorry for myself at all because I got the best boys in the world. I was ignorant. I am still pretty pissed off though that I did not get to "Have it all" I'm so stubborn.
I always liked balance though too to a certain degree. I would have to have 2 boys and a girl or three boys and two girls but I didn't want that many so thought I would have to just have three. Now I am happy to compromise. Just one daughter please is all I wish for.
Oh and I used to not be able to put two different coloured pegs on an item on the washing line and I couldn't drink water without counting. I had to have 7 or 10 gulps at once. I don't have time for any of that now though so dropped the washing thing but sometimes still do the water thingDPs sons21 +
13
11 + our
6
4 year old identical twins!
I might actually be over my deep yearning for aand it's an exciting feeling
-
March 17th, 2015, 05:40 AM #30
Also I have always been highly more attracted to odd numbers. I always loved to be different
Similar Threads
-
Thoughts?
By LouandtheWho in forum Ultrasound Gender PredictionReplies: 6Last Post: September 23rd, 2014, 09:14 PM -
Thoughts on LR??
By QueenB3blue in forum Trying to Conceive a GirlReplies: 7Last Post: August 11th, 2014, 03:46 PM -
My son's vs (???). Thoughts? :)
By psl46 in forum Ultrasound Gender PredictionReplies: 3Last Post: May 24th, 2013, 12:19 PM -
I think boy, please say your thoughts??
By ecrand in forum Ultrasound Gender PredictionReplies: 12Last Post: July 3rd, 2012, 07:50 PM -
My thoughts of why BD AF-O may not be good, any thoughts?does this make sense or no?
By mkarntz1980 in forum Trying to Conceive a GirlReplies: 4Last Post: February 26th, 2011, 04:02 PM